Pymatuning Lake walleyes still abundant, maybe easier to catch

Posted on: September 3, 2019 | Bob Frye | Comments

Walleye fishing is fun.

Fish and Baot Commission biologist Tim Wilson holds a big Pymatuning Lake walleye.
Photo: PA Fish and Boat Commission

Maybe nature is balancing itself out at Pymatuning Lake.

Anglers can’t be blamed for hoping so.

For years, biologists with the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission have talked about how many walleyes swim in the 17,088 acre lake in Crawford County. .It’s the centerpiece of Pymatuning State Park, on the Pennsylvania-Ohio border.

They survey the lake every spring, counting walleyes and other fish caught. They have since at least 1989.

The news recently has been nothing but good.

Biologists reported their best walleye catch ever in 2014. The years 2018, 2017, 2019 and 2015, in that order, ranked next.

This spring, for example, biologists caught 3,296 walleyes, said Tim Wilson a biologist working out of the commission’s Linesville office. That’s enough to make them, by far, the most common fish caught in trap nets.

That includes some nice fish, too. The smallest walleyes seen stretched 7 inches; the largest 29. The majority are 16 to 22, with the average a very nice 19 inches.

Walleyes must be 15 inches to be legal for harvest.

Despite all that, Pymatuning’s walleyes have proven elusive.

Wilson said the commission received “numerous” complaints from fishermen and women in 2017. All lamented how hard it was to get walleyes to bite.

The problem, Wilson said, was food. There was simply too much of it in the lake.

Pymatuning Lake's walleyes eat lots of things.

Here, from left, are a gizzard shad, alewife, golden shiner and spottail shiner.
Photo: PA Fish and Boat Commission.

“We attributed the relatively poor fishing to the much higher than normal abundance of forage we saw during our 2017 trap net survey. Gizzard Shad, alewives and spottail shiners were all well above their long-term averages of relative abundance,” he noted.

But that continues to change, in a good way for anglers.

Biologists collect those forage fish in their survey nets, too. And they got fewer last year than the year before, and “substantially” fewer this year still.

That’s not to say they’re disappearing. There’s still plenty for the lake’s walleyes and other fish to eat, Wilson said.

“This forage base provides excellent growth and survival rates for all the predators in Pymatuning Reservoir,” Wilson said.

But they’re no longer so numerous that the lake’s walleyes are all full all the time.

And that should – potentially, in theory or however else anyone wants to describe it — make them easier to catch, at least relatively speaking..

Pymatuning Lake’s other fish

Aside from walleyes, anglers can have fun targeting other fish in Pymatuning.

Yellow perch are the next most abundant species in the lake. Their numbers climbed again this spring, which has been the long-term trend.

They tend to be small, though.

Biologists handled 2,518. Some went as large as 12 inches.

But 55 percent were shorter than 6 inches, and another 32 percent between 7 and 9. Only 13 percent were 9 inches or longer. That’s the size preferred by anglers.

Until that changes, Wilson said, the perch at least provide another prey species for walleyes and other larger game fish.

The story is better right now with two other species.

Channel catfish still provide an excellent fishery. The muskellunge population remains in good shape and angler reports suggest targeting them is productive. Many anglers targeting other species report catching small muskellunge, which bodes well for the future,” Wilson said.

The crappie fishery – also hugely popular at Pymatuning – remains good, if not historic.

Biologists caught more black crappies than white. And the average fish was “impressive,” some of them going 14 inches, Wilson said. But overall numbers were down a lot compared to 2018.

Angler harvest is the most likely reason why, he suggested.


See also: Examining the origin of walleyes


Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Bob Frye is the editor. Reach him at 412-838-5148 or See other stories, blogs, videos and more at

Share This Article

Shop special Everybody Adventure products today!