Things may get worse for grouse before they get better

Posted on: October 18, 2017 | Bob Frye | Comments

There’s a chance Pennsylvania’s grouse will one day rise from the ashes where they reside now.

Just don’t expect it this fall.

It looks as though things might get worse before they get better.

Lisa Williams, grouse biologist for the Pennsylvania Game Commission, said populations are at a 50-year low. That’s a continuation of a troubling trend. Numbers have been depressed for several years now.

“We’re now kind of hitting record lows year after year,” she said.

Even in areas of good habitat, grouse are struggling.

It’s not just here either.

“Most of our neighbors are at record lows or near record lows for grouse populations, too. This is not anything unique to Pennsylvania,” Williams said. “But it certainly is concerning.”

West Nile Virus is thought to be a large part of the problem. Birds bitten by mosquitoes carrying the disease suffer heart and brain damage, often leading to death.

And this year has been a bad one on that front.

Pennsylvania’s Department of Environmental Protection monitors for the disease annually. It turned up in April this year, which was a “record early detection for the virus on the landscape,” Williams said.

“We know we are in an exceptionally bad year for the virus. And that leads to an exceptionally bad year for grouse,” she added.

Still, most of the Department of Environmental Protection’s surveying goes on around human population centers. Grouse are not a focus.

So this summer, the commission collected mosquitoes on its own, on state game land 176 in Centre County. The idea was to see if infected mosquitoes are as troublesome in that kind of habitat as elsewhere.

The answer is yes.

Using two different kinds of traps, the commission caught mosquitoes two days a week for 10 weeks. They collected 13,190 of 25 different varieties.

“We did find eight species that I say fall into that Goldilocks zone. They’re just right for what we want to look at,” Williams said.

“In other words, they are carrying the virus and they bite birds.”

None of that is good news.

The problem is widespread, too.

The commission has examined hunter harvest birds for evidence of West Nile over the last two years. It’s examined about 400. They’ve come from 41 of the state’s 67 counties.

Everywhere, the disease has cropped up.

“Essentially what we have seen is that where we have grouse, we have West Nile effecting grouse,” Williams said.

The good news, “if there is any,” she added, is that some grouse can survive a West Nile infection.

“Once they get the disease and they recover, that protection probably lasts for their lifetime. So that gives us some management opportunities,” Williams said.

They come on three fronts, all of which must be tackled simultaneously, she added.

First, Williams said, the commission needs to figure out if it’s possible to control the disease at all, perhaps by treating certain types of stagnant water bodies.

In natural wetlands, with dragonflies and other predatory insects, mosquitoes don’t necessarily get out of control, Williams said. Smaller wet spots don’t see that, though.

Perhaps, she said, there are opportunities there.

Second, it needs to “work smarter, not harder,” when it comes to habitat.

“If we can identify areas where the disease risk is lower, that’s where we should be putting habitat,” Williams said.

The southeast region of the state, for example, has a lot of survivors among grouse, she said. The northwest and northcentral have the most and best habitat.

It might be wise to work in such places and allow survivors to disperse, or “build outward.”

Third, it needs to focus on harvest management. That means limiting take to increase the percentage of disease-resistant birds in the breeding population.

The commission closed the post-Christmas grouse season for 2017-18. Williams didn’t say if that might have to remain closed or if other seasons might need to be shortened.

She won’t make season recommendations for next year until January.

But the commission needs to increase virus-resistant birds as a percentage of the breeding population, she added.

If all that comes together, the birds could respond. But they need help now.

“The concern is that as these bad years come closer and closer together, if that’s going to be a pattern, then we really have an urgent management situation, even where we have good grouse populations,” she said.

Finding ways to bring doves, dove hunters together

They’re common in some other states and fairly popular, too.

But Pennsylvania’s never tried them.

That could change.

Game Commission officials – with an eye toward providing wingshooters action — are looking into the possibility of creating managed dove fields on state game lands.

Such fields are, according to the Missouri Department of Conservation – which creates many annually – “planted in sunflowers, wheat, millet, buckwheat, corn or a combination of these.”

They’re harvested to put seed on the ground and attract doves, said former Game Commissioner Dave Putnam of Centre County.

That goes on in stages, said commission president Brian Hoover of Chester County. Habitat crews cut down four or five rows of crops one week, then go back to do another four or five the next week, he said.

Ian Gregg, game management division chief for the Game Commission, said wildlife agencies in a number of states – West Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina and Missouri, among others – manage fields for doves. Some are open to hunters without restriction; others require a permit, albeit only at certain times, like opening day, to limit pressure.

The commission is investigating whether it might make sense to develop some here.

There are pros and cons to the idea, Gregg said.

The pros, he said, is that managed fields are popular with hunters. In other states, especially early in the season, before hunting for other species starts, they draw good crowds.

The cons are that they are labor intensive and therefore somewhat costly, he said. Their popularity wanes as the season progresses, he added.

The commission’s investigation is ongoing; Gregg said. No decisions have been made and may not be for a while.

“There’s still a lot more we need to do to figure out what we might want to do with this,” he said.

Bob Frye is the editor. Reach him at 412-838-5148 or See other stories, blogs, videos and more at

Share This Article

Shop special Everybody Adventure products today!

Bob Frye is a storyteller with a passion for all things outdoors. He hunts, he fishes, he hikes, he camps, he paddles, backpacks and snowshoes depending on the season. If he’s not an expert at anything, it’s because he’s passionate to try a little bit of everything.